Research and Analysis of Goldhizer’s Report

In this report, Goldhizer has rejected the traditions that have been quoted from Prophet (p.b.u.h.) and have considered them to be faked and forged a century or more after the death of Prophet (p.b.u.h.).

          He is a renowned Jew who considers these narrations to have emerged as a result of the political conflicts that took place after the Prophet (p.b.u.h.).

          He succeeded Wellhousen in the act of rejecting the narrations of Prophet (p.b.u.h.) and moreover, he also praised the Umayyad Dynasty. After him, Lamenz praised them in a greater manner.

          Writers in America and Germany followed the path of Wellhousen and acclaimed the Umayyad lineage.

          A significant question arises here, whose answer can explore many other principal issues and it is: Why did some of the Jewish writers and their supporters like Goldziher and Wellhouaen reject the authenticity of the narrations of Holy Prophet (p.b.u.h.) and regarded them as faked and forged after the demise of the Prophet?

          We will answer this question by stating that even after all the efforts made by Umar for restricting the collection and distribution of narrations between the Muslims, there were a few Muslims who wrote down the narrations of the Prophet and distributed them amongst the people. In this way, many of the sayings of the Holy Prophet (p.b.u.h.) remained within the access of the people.

          Among the narrations which are collected in the books of the two sects (Shias and Sunnis), there exists such narrations that are of great political importance along with their religious aspect. Out of these, prophesies of the Holy Prophet regarding the Umayyad dynasty are notable.

In these predictions, which have been mentioned in a detailed manner in this book, Prophet (p.b.u.h.) has warned the people and the entire nation about their evil deeds, from not just the religious aspect but also the political prospective.

          As these predictions have reached the extent of precision, and the Sunni clerics have also quoted these narrations in their books, there isn’t any point of skepticism regarding the tyrannical attitude of the Umayyad Dynasty. Moreover, their enmity with the religion and the progeny of Holy Prophet (p.b.u.h.), before his prophet-hood, during the era of his Prophet-hood and after his demise, is clearly evident.  

          Those Jews who have indulged themselves in research works and have attempted to wipe of the evil stains from the clothes of the Umayyad dynasty, had no other option but to reject all the sayings of the Prophet (p.b.u.h.) from their very roots.

          It is evident that a person who accepts all those prophesies regarding the different aspects of the Umayyad Dynasty, with reference to a particular individual or on an overall basis, will not be able to prove them as the supporters of the religion by any means.

          The Jews and their supporters who live in America, Germany or any other country and aid them, have denied the narrations of the Holy Prophet (p.b.u.h.) in order to revive the misleading beliefs of the Umayyad (which is propagated by the Wahhabis at present), so that by nurturing and propagating the misguiding beliefs of the Umayyad lineage, they can preach the Wahhabi beliefs in the society.

          Due to the defeat of the Umayyad dynasty and the disintegration of their rule, their power vanished and gradually, their name began to fade and was finally forgotten.

          As the Jews lost all hopes of the formation of a new Umayyad rule in the Muslims countries, they laid down a new conspiracy and decided to revive and resurrect the Umayyad thoughts and beliefs between the Muslims.

This was for the purpose of invoking dispute between the Muslims (which was the age old intention of the Jews), and also for propagating the Umayyad thoughts and beliefs (who held enmity against the Holy Prophet and his progeny) between the Islamic Nation.

          Those who are aware of the history and who perform their historical research and analysis with an honest viewpoint, also know this fact that the Umayyad dynasty had an age old enmity with the Hashemite lineage, even before the era of Prophet-hood, and they have continued this enmity by hiding it in a hypocritical manner even after the arrival of Islam, although, they have unleashed themselves and revealed their true face many a times.

          Such researchers and scholars will easily understand that the Wahhabis are nothing but the revivers of the Umayyad tradition and the propagators of their Anti-Islam thoughts and beliefs.

          Enmity with Allah and His Messenger (p.b.u.h.), hostility against the Divine Progeny, demolishing of the graves and destruction of the souvenirs of the Holy Prophet, creating obstruction in the progress of Islam, having relations with the Jews and Christians and propagating their agenda, enmity with the Holy Kabah and acclaiming the Bait al Muqaddas against the Kabah, these are the significant conspiracies laid down by the Umayyad which are now being propagated by the Wahhabis.

          In order to understand the role of the Umayyad dynasty in the fulfillment of Jewish motives, we will quote some of the thoughts and deeds of Hajjaj – who was one of the most ruthless and brutal rulers of the Umayyad Dynasty, along with Abdul Malik.